Have you ever gone to a bank or a financial planner looking for advice, and did you come away with a new RRSP, debt consolidation loan, or home equity line of credit instead?

In Sandi’s banker past, she had a client list of over 6000 individuals, families, and small businesses. Those customers were coming to the bank for service and advice, while the bank thought they were coming in to buy something.

Banks and commission-based financial advisors and planners are in the business of selling, not servicing. Do you think management would have been happy if after a client appointment Sandi’s report was “Mrs. Somebody has reduced the amount she spends in service fees, got help building her household budget, made a plan to pay down her debt within the next three years, and switched her investments to low-cost index funds, but she didn’t sign up for (yet another) credit card”?

Professional financial planners should be compensated for their knowledge, experience, and advice, not for the products they sell you, and a planner who charges a flat fee to discuss your goals, analyze your current situation, build a plan to get you where you want to be, and is compensated only by you is a “fee only” or “advice only” or “fee for service” financial planner.

Anyone offering “free” financial planning and who also conveniently sells insurance and investments is compensated by the investment or insurance company when they sell those products to you.

These people are – on balance – honest, smart, helpful people who really do want to help you. But if the only way they are compensated or can please their manager is if you purchase something from them, can the advice they’re giving you be completely free?

As you’d expect, we’ve written quite a lot on the topic of fee only and advice only financial planning:

Read more:

 

High Value Banking: How Much is the Royal Treatment Worth to You?

(This article is reposted with the permission of the author. It was originally published here Boomer & Echo.) Imagine this scenario: you’ve gone into the bank to see about setting up a home equity line of credit, or buying a cottage, or increasing your regular...

February 2019 Update

  Happy Lunar New Year! If you’re a regular reader, you already know that some of the team got together at the end of January to retreat and discuss what we did in 2018 and what we’re hoping to do in 2019. Our annual executive retreat, facilitated by the fabulous...

2018 Spring Financial Gift Guide

If you’re reading this financial gift guide, presumably you’re interested in helping your friends and family get better at managing their money and making great decisions about their lives. That’s good. When you give gifts like these, there’s a real danger that the...

Finding the RIGHT Financial Advisor

Given the sheer number of articles, 10 point lists, podcasts, and even books out there on the subject, it’s time to face the truth: choosing a financial advisor is hard. We are asked all kinds of questions in many different ways that all boil down to the same...

October 2018 Update

  For many of our clients, one of the most frustrating moments of working with expert advisors is when you have this realization: There is rarely one “right” answer. Even when you process this initial realization, and think to yourself, “Sure, everyone is...

September 2018 Update

Now that summer is officially over (boo! hisss!) it’s time for one of our all-time favourite activities at Spring: using what we’ve learned about ourselves to make life better - for ourselves, our families, our team, and our clients. (We swear we’re fun at...

May 2018 Update

You might not know this, but at Spring, we kiss a lot of frogs. In my neck of the woods, it’s spring peeper season, which means that if you’re near a pond at dusk you’ll hear a chorus of tiny little frogs making some of the most beautiful music on earth. (Have a...